‘The stars at night are big and bright, deep in the heart of Texas…’
The Problem
Texas is at risk of losing its dark sky and natural nighttime environment to excessive light pollution.
The International Dark-Sky Association defines light pollution as “the inappropriate or excessive use of artificial light.” Light pollution affects the health of all Texans, the environment, wildlife, and our ability to find awe in the natural night. Unnecessary nighttime light can disproportionately impact specific regions of the state, having a larger negative impact on the Hill Country tourism region of Texas. According to the Office of the Governor: Culture & Tourism Division, this region accounts for 84,900 tourism related jobs and $9.8 billion in direct travel spending. Many of these tourists report visiting to experience the natural beauty of the Hill Country, including stargazing and astronomical phenomena.
Limiting unnecessary nighttime lighting ensures people will continue to enjoy the wonder of Texas’s dark sky.
Solutions | Current Efforts to Protect the Dark Sky in Texas
Support Senate Bill 1090
Scenic Texas is the only statewide nonprofit whose mission is focused on preserving the scenic and visual beauty of the state. For 37 years we have been carrying on the vision of Texas the Beautiful as our state’s former first lady Lady Bird Johnson defined it.
Scenic Texas advocates for a number of policies affecting the preservation of Texas’ natural resources, including the preservation of the night sky from harmful light pollution. Stars are scenic. According to recent studies, it is estimated the Milky Way is no longer visible to fully one-third of humanity — including 80 percent of Americans.
Texas has a number of recognized International Dark Sky Association (IDA) Communities, which are communities that, among many other actions, have passed lighting ordinances in compliance with IDA guidelines to protect the night sky from light pollution.
Scenic Texas has worked with interested stakeholders and Senator Buckingham on SB 1090, an agreed-to fix that addresses a minor and unintended consequence that arose following the passage of HB 2439 in the 86th session limiting the ability of communities to become an IDA community.
Senate Bill 1090 exempts lighting ordinances as long as a governmental entity adopts a resolution stating its intent to become a IDA community and regulates lighting in a manner that is not more restrictive than necessary to become IDA certified.
This bill upholds the original intent of the 2019 legislation, while allowing for communities seeking to become IDA certified to do so.
As a Texan by Nature Conservation Partner, we agree with the Former First Lady Laura Bush’s organizational focus on the Lights Out initiative that communities and businesses across the state are currently taking part in through May 7. The IDA defines light pollution as “the inappropriate or excessive use of artificial light.” Light pollution affects the health of all Texans, the environment, wildlife, and our ability to find awe in the natural night. Unnecessary nighttime light can disproportionately impact specific regions of the state, having a larger negative impact on the astro tourism industry that is growing in Texas.
Forbes, is calling astro tourism the “Next Big Thing” in tourism and Texas is uniquely positioned thanks to our McDonald Observatory, state and national parks, and communities like IDA Certified Dripping Springs that are leading the way in stargazing and preserving the night sky.
The next big total solar eclipse will be on April 8, 2024 and astronomy experts are saying the place to see it is will be in the Texas Hill Country (much like Jackson Hole, WY was the place to be in 2017).
SB 1090 will help communities that want to protect the dark sky, mitigate light pollution, and enhance this natural scenic resource for tourism and residential quality of life.
San Antonio
The city has implemented a Military Lighting Overlay District to regulate nighttime lighting around Camp Bullis/Camp Stanley and Randolph and Lackland Air Force Bases. Also, see San Antonio’s Dark Sky Policy Evaluation Staff Research here.
McDonald Observatory
In the 82nd regular legislative session (2011), Governor Perry signed into law legislation that applies to “a municipality located in a county any part of which is located within 57 miles of a major astronomical observatory at the McDonald Observatory.”
The statute allows and instructs the 7 counties within a 57-mile radius of the McDonald Observatory to establish provisions relating to the regulation of outdoor lighting. The seven counties (Jeff Davis, Brewster, Presidio, Hudspeth, Culberson, Reeves, and Pecos) surrounding the campus have outdoor lighting ordinances and all the cities within these counties have similar municipal ordinances. This represents 28,000 square miles of land with outdoor lighting ordinances, for the protection of dark skies.
Hill Country Alliance
To date, 15 of the 17 counties making up the Hill Country Alliance, an organization dedicated to the enhancement and preservation of the region, have passed resolutions supporting efforts to pass dark skies legislation.
Current Efforts to Protect the Natural Nighttime Environment Across the Country
At least 18 states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico have laws in place to reduce light pollution. The majority of states that have enacted “dark skies” legislation have done so to promote energy conservation, public safety, aesthetic interests and astronomical research capabilities.
Most state laws are limited to outdoor lighting fixtures installed on the grounds of a state building or facility or on a public roadway. The most common dark skies legislation requires the installation of shielded light fixtures which emit light only downward. Replacement of unshielded with fully shielded lighting units often allows for use of a lower wattage bulb, resulting in energy savings. Other laws require the use of low-glare or low-wattage lighting, regulate the amount of time that certain lighting can be used, and the incorporation of Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) guidelines into state regulations.
Recommendations
Bracket Hill Country Counties.
The American Medical Association recommends the use of 3000K or lower lighting for outdoor installations such as roadways. Additionally, they suggest all LED lighting should be properly shielded to minimize glare and detrimental human and environmental effects, and consideration should be given to utilize the ability of LED lighting to be dimmed for off-peak time periods.
“Thirty-three percent of all outdoor lighting is wasted by going where it’s not intended to go,” Cliff Kaplan of Hill Country Alliance said. That waste translates to 15 million tons of wasted carbon dioxide and $3 billion spent on unintended lighting nationwide.
